WU Yang, LIU Haiyu, KOU Mengnan, et al. Comparative analysis of methanol and traditional boiler fuel based on AHP-EWM[J]. Thermal power generation, 2023, 52(10): 113-121.
WU Yang, LIU Haiyu, KOU Mengnan, et al. Comparative analysis of methanol and traditional boiler fuel based on AHP-EWM[J]. Thermal power generation, 2023, 52(10): 113-121. DOI: 10.19666/j.rlfd.202304382.
基于AHP-EWM的甲醇与传统锅炉燃料对比分析
摘要
在“双碳”目标背景下,环保要求日益严格,甲醇作为公认的高效清洁低碳燃料越来越受到重视。为分析甲醇用于锅炉燃料的可行性,建立了甲醇、煤、柴油、天然气作为锅炉燃料的综合性评价模型,通过层次分析法(analytic hierarchy process
Under the background of the goal of “carbon peak and carbon neutrality”
environmental protection requirements are becoming increasingly stringent
and methanol as a recognized high-efficiency
clean and lowcarbon fuel has received more and more attention. In order to analyze the feasibility of methanol for boiler fuel
a comprehensive evaluation model of methanol
coal
diesel and natural gas as boiler fuel was established
and the four indicators of energy saving
environmental protection
economy and sociality were considered through analytic hierarchy process(AHP) and entropy weight method(EWM)
and comprehensive evaluation was carried out under five scenarios with different importance of each index. The following conclusions are drawn: the energy saving of methanol is better than that of other fuels
the environmental protection and economy are comparable to natural gas
and the social aspect is second only to coal
which is 3.2 times that of diesel and 2.2 times that of natural gas; in terms of importance
environmental factors first
economic factors and energy-saving factors second
social factors are the weakest importance(scenario 3); the comprehensive evaluation score of methanol as boiler fuel is 0.318 6
which has great advantages compared with natural gas(0.292 9)