王桂林, 李彪, 廖明勇, et al. Fuzzy comprehensive evaluation method for grouting quality by integrating rock wall integrity[J]. Journal of Hydroelectric Engineering, 2026, 45(5).
王桂林, 李彪, 廖明勇, et al. Fuzzy comprehensive evaluation method for grouting quality by integrating rock wall integrity[J]. Journal of Hydroelectric Engineering, 2026, 45(5).DOI: 10.11660/slfdxb.20260505.
This paper develops a new comprehensive evaluation method of grouting quality with multi-indices synergy
to solve the problem that the traditional evaluation methods rely on a single index and suffer poor capability of reflecting the behaviors of grouted rock mass. First
we construct an index system with four indicators: post-grouting Lugeon value
rock wall integrity index
acoustic wave speed
and unit grout consumption
in order to evaluate the dual criteria of permeability and compactness. Then
we use an analytic hierarchy procedure and the entropy weight method to calculate subjective and objective weights separately
and combine the weights to balance expert experience and data characteristics through applying the game theory. Finally
we achieve the quantitative grading of grouting quality by constructing a membership degree matrix based on the fuzzy comprehensive evaluation method. Application to a hydropower station project in Southwest China shows a comprehensive evaluation weight vector of [0.396
0.2655
0.1658
0.2091]T and the grouting quality indices of 4.307
3.769
4.356
and 4.365 for the four evaluation units respectively. Compared with the traditional single-index method
this new method gives the same overall trend of grouting quality
but can identify local weak grouting areas with higher accuracy. This study demonstrates the advantages of multi-indices synergy
rational weighting
and robust evaluation of our new method
and lays a basis for better grouting quality assessment and supplementary grouting decision-making.