WANG Zhucheng, MENG Guixiang, YAO Sheng, et al. Difference in boiler efficiency calculation between ASME PTC4.1—1964 and ASME PTC4—2013[J]. Thermal power generation, 2018, 47(11): 1-6.
DOI:
WANG Zhucheng, MENG Guixiang, YAO Sheng, et al. Difference in boiler efficiency calculation between ASME PTC4.1—1964 and ASME PTC4—2013[J]. Thermal power generation, 2018, 47(11): 1-6. DOI: 10.19666/j.rlfd.201803102.
Difference in boiler efficiency calculation between ASME PTC4.1—1964 and ASME PTC4—2013
The commonly used standards of boiler performance test in China are briefly introduced
including Chinese standards and American standards. Because different standard versions will bring differences in the test results
it is necessary to study how to use different standard versions
thus to help engineers better understand and master the utilization of different standard versions in actual projects. The differences of boiler efficiency calculation method between ASME PTC4.1—1964 and ASME PTC4—2013 are discussed
and the difference in definition and application range of boiler efficiency
as well as the reference temperature and main heat loss calculation
are compared in detail. The calculation results of the performance test case show that: if the physical input heat is ignored
the relative deviation of the boiler efficiency calculated by the two standards is 0.054%; if the physical input heat is considered
the relative deviation of the gross efficiency calculated by the two standards is 0.055%
and the relative deviation of the fuel efficiency is 0.079%.